The Grandstander: A New York State of Mind

With apologies to Long Island's Billy Joel, Linda and I were indeed in a New York state of mind this past week as we spent about 48 hours in the Big Apple and we jammed quite a lot into those two days.

The main purpose of the trip was to see the revival of Meredith Willson's "The Music Man" starring Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster. We also tacked on the revival of another play, Neil Simon's "Plaza Suite", which starred the real life husband and wife team of Matthew Broderick and Sarah Jessica Parker. I'll spare you the suspense of waiting until the end of the post: both productions get the full Four Stars from The Grandstander!

"The Music Man" has long been one of my favorite shows. I have seen several stage productions and watched the movie version more times than I can count. When it was announced that this was going to be revived with Jackman and Foster in the lead roles, Marilyn and made a vow to travel to New York and see it. Of course, COVID shutdowns delayed the opening of the production, and sadly, fate decreed that Marilyn was not to see it. I still wanted to see it, so the plans were made to do so earlier this year, so there we were at the Wintergreen Theater this past Tuesday evening.

As for the production, it's hard to imagine anyone but Robert Preston as Harold Hill, but let's face it, Hugh Jackman is HUGH JACKMAN, a major international star of stage and screen, and Sutton Foster is a multi-Tony Award winning Broadway star, so you were going to see them every bit as much as you were going to see the show. They were great and they more than did justice to this classic show. Highlights for us were, of course, "Trouble", the staging of "The Wells Fargo Wagon", and the choreography of the "Marian the Librarian" number, during which there were spots where all cast members tossed library books at each other in a game of catch that was flawless. Not one book dropped. And the curtain call! The curtain call was a show and a production number unto itself. It was amazing, as was the entire show.

Also to be noted: Tony nominated Jayne Houdyshell as Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn was tremendous. Also, Benjamin Pajek, Kayla Teruel, Emma Crow, and Gino Coscullela. the young actors who played, respectively, Winthrop, Amaryllis, Zaneeta, and Tommy were each making their Broadway debuts in this show. And while Jefferson Mays gave a game effort as Mayor Shinn, he was no Paul Ford, but who could be in that role?

We decided that our second show to see would be "Plaza Suite" because (a) we thought it would be nice to see a play instead of a musical, (b) it's a Neil Simon play so it would be funny, and (c) the stars, Broderick and Parker. We were not disappointed.

In the summer of 1969, as a part of my high school graduation gift, my Dad took me to New York on one of his business trips. The Broadway show we saw there was "Plaza Suite". That was fifty-three years ago, Seeing it on Wednesday, I realized a couple of things:

Neil Simon was an authentic genius of American comedy and culture. His comedy is timeless. The producers of this show made the choice to keep the play set in 1968-69, the time when it was written and first produced. Thus, you have reference to a wedding at the Plaza costing $8,000. There is no need to alter the time or setting of this show.
Broderick and Parker are real pros. When you have only seen them on TV or in movies, seeing them live and on stage is a revelation. They know how to play to an audience. Also, I never thought of either of them as being physical comedic actors, but they were amazing in performing the physical schtick required of them in this play.
I loved this show and laughed uproariously, sheiekingly so, on several occasions, and I also appreciated some of the more bittersweet observations that Simon sprinkled into the show. I also know that while I enjoyed the show when I saw it back in 1969, there could have been no way that I would have appreciated it nearly as much as a seventeen year old than I appreciated it now.

By the way, the show biz marriage of Broderick and Parker has now lasted for twenty-five years and, apparently, is still going strong. Could you have imagined this scene at the dinner table one evening? "What would you like to do this year, dear?" "Well, how about we do a Neil Simon play on Broadway? That would probably be fun."

The shows aside, we had an absolute ball in New York. I spent one afternoon in the city with Bill and Joann Montrose in 2017, but had not spent any extended time there since a week long business trip in 1983, so it was like being there for the first time. The noise, the thousands upon thousands of people, the constant activity. It was a forty-eight hour adrenaline rush for both of us. We have vowed to make a trip like this an annual event, at least, for us.

There were many highlights. Highlights like....

Remember the scene in "The Godfather" where Luca Brasi was stabbed in the hand with an icepick and garroted to death? That as filmed at the bar in the Hotel Edison where we stayed. We had a drink there. The name of the restaurant is Bond 45, and I am amazed that there isn't an historical plaque there to commemorate it.
Walking through Times Square at 11:00 on a Tuesday night amidst thousands, tens of thousands, of people. It was loud noisy, colorful, entertaining, and thrilling. The City truly does never sleep.
Meeting Loyal Littles Podcast co-hosts "Chuck and Roxy", aka, Louis and Megan. They joined us for dinner on Wednesday night, and what nice people they are. A delightful couple of hours. In addition to hosting the podcast, he is a Broadway musician and conductor, and she is a Radio City Rockette.

On the recommendation of our friend Winnie, we stayed at the Hotel Edison on West 47th Street, and mere two blocks from Times Square. Convenient and within walking distance of a ton of theaters and other attractions such as Rockefeller Center, Radio City Music Hall, and St. Patrick's Cathedral. Thanks for the tip,Winnie!

The hotel was right across the street from the Richard Rodgers Theater, where "Hamilton" is playing. On Wednesday afternoon as we walked back to our hotel, Linda notices a guy in costume leaning out of a stage door and shmoozing with the theater security guard. He was wearing a green period costume, which I recognized as the costume of Alexander Hamilton himself. I recognized him as Miguel Cervantes the actor whom I know is currently playing the title role in New York, and who played the role when Marilyn and I saw the show in Chicago in 2017. I went up to him and said so, to which he replied, "well, you need to come in here and see it again!" After shaking my hand, he cut short the conversation by saying, "I'm due back on stage right now." It was Wednesday, matinee day! The guard told me that if wasn't in the middle of a performance, he'd have stayed and chatted endlessly with me. So THAT was one pretty cool experience!
New York is expensive, no doubt about it, but you can find bargains. While strolling the streets in the afternoon, we found a pizza joint the offered "two New York slices and a can of soda" for $3.99! When we were leaving the theater after "Plaza Suite", it was pouring rain, but standing right outside the door was guy selling umbrellas for five bucks apiece. Those crappy umbrellas may not survive a gentle breeze, but they got us through the four block walk back to the hotel, and they now sit in each of our cars for emergency situations.
A shout out to the Brooklyn Chop House, the restaurant across West 46th Street from our hotel. Just opened in April, we stopped there for a nightcap after "The Music Man" on Tuesday, and we liked it so much that we met Chuck and Roxie there for dinner the following night. The place was gorgeous, the food was good, and the staff couldn't have been more friendly and accommodating. There was a reason that they were so nice with us, but that is "the rest of the story" and one that I am not going to put in this space, at least, not yet. I'll be happy to share it with you face to face, though, if the occasion arrises. Regardless, put the Brooklyn Chop House on you list of places to eat next time you go to New York.

One big step into the 2020's for us....out plane tickets/boarding passes for our return trip home were on our phones. No paper!
I mentioned my late friend Bill Montrose earlier. No one loved and appreciated Broadway and New York more. Marilyn and I saw "Beautiful" on Broadway with Joann and him back in 2018, and I think of him every time I see a play or a musical. How I wish he were still with us so I could share the stories of this trip. You had better believe that a toast was raised to him both nights that we were there.

Okay, I've been rambling, so I am going to wrap this up for now, even though I know that as soon as I hit "Publish" I will think of something else I should have put in here. I will just conclude with a couple of random photos from the trip for you pleasure (maybe?) and for my own historical record. These are in no particular order.

Home of the Mets