data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d5c0b/d5c0b5bb48a5f843a14596a3ea0a6cb1242f5405" alt=""
Aiken is at first reluctant to participate in the defense of a conspirator in the plot that killed the President. He soon comes to realize that while he may be uncertain as to Surratt's guilt or innocence, he is fully aware that she is being denied the rights of all citizens under the Constitution, which he fought to uphold: the presumption of innocence, and trial by a jury of her peers, all in the name of "national security" and the "greater good" of the nation. Here is where the movie gets a bit ham-handed. One can't help but see that Redford is drawing a parallel to events going on today. In fact, substitute Dick Cheney for Secretary of War Edwin Stanton, and you get the idea.
All that aside, it is a very well done movie, and it certainly does raise questions about the fairness of the trial of Mary Surratt and as to whether or not justice was done. Wright and McAvoy are very good in their roles. Stanton is played by one of my favorite actors, Kevin Kline, and I have to admit that I didn't even realize it was him until the ending credits.
Any American history buff will enjoy seeing this movie.
By the way, as I watched The Conspirator, Marilyn was in another theater in the multi-plex watching "Water for Elephants." She gave it a thumbs up for any of you who might be interested.
Thanks Grandstander. I read "The Day Lincoln Was Shot" by Jim Bishop when I was in maybe 8th grade. Years ago I read all of Shelby Footes Civil War books and before him, Bruce Catton. I will be a hard man to sway concerning the innocence of Mrs. Surratt, but I'm sure I'll love the movie for many of the reasons you've mentioned.
ReplyDeleteDan, note that I (and by extension, the movie) did not say Mrs Surratt was innocent. Rather, I said it "raise(s)questions about the fairness of the trial of Mary Surratt and as to whether or not justice was done."
ReplyDeleteTwo very different things as I am sure you will agree when you see the movie.