Showing posts with label Terry Bradshaw. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Terry Bradshaw. Show all posts

Friday, February 26, 2021

The Quarterback Reveal

To refresh your memories, yesterday in this space I asked you to put yourself in the place of an NFL General manager and said that....

...you have your choice between two young quarterbacks at the relative same stage in their career development.


Quarterback A

Quarterback B

Games Played

15

13

Games Started

9

8

Record as Starter

5-4

3-5

Attempts

326

218

Completions

201

83

%

61.7%

38.1%

Yards passing

2,089

1,410

TDs

15

6

Interceeptions

10

24

QBR

82.7

30.4

Okay, which one will you take?

Now it is time to identify these two young hotshot QBs, and I am sure that many of you, especially you Steelers fans out there, have no doubt guessed who they are.

Quarterback A is current Steelers back up Mason Rudolph.


Quarterback B is Hall of Famer and four time Super Bowl champion, two time Super Bowl MVP Terry Bradshaw, seen below at an age when he was putting up those horrible numbers back in 1970.


So why, you may ask, did I do this comparison.  Let me say right off the bat it is not to suggest that Rudolph is or ever will be better than Terry Bradshaw.  That would be ridiculous.  No, what prompted this was a remark by 93.7 The Fan's morning  hot take artist Colin Dunlap earlier in the week.  In one of the endless discussions about the future of Ben Roethlisberger, Dunlap stated "well we KNOW (emphasis mine) that Mason Rudolph sucks...."  Dunlap was basing this statement on how "terrible" (his word) Rudolph has been in the opportunities that he has had over the last two seasons with the Steelers.

Well, I thought to myself, I remember Bradshaw's early seasons with the Steelers, so I wonder what Dunlap, who was born in 1976, would have had to say about Terry Bradshaw in the formative years of his career?  I am glad that talk radio, as it exists today, was not around back in 1970 because surely the Colin Dunlaps at the time would have been boiling tar and plucking feathers to ride Bradshaw out of town on a rail.  In fact, there were people who felt that way.  People who thought that Bradshaw was a country bumpkin oaf who would never amount to anything and that Terry Hanratty from Butler High School and Notre Dame was the guy to whom the Steelers should go at quarterback.  I remember it vividly.  Colin Dunlap does not because he wan't born yet.

All that prompted me to dig into the records and come up with the comparison you see above.

It has always been my thought, for whatever that might be worth, that Mason Rudolph can be a good, maybe even a very good, NFL quarterback.  No, I am not suggesting that he will be Ben or Terry, very few quarterbacks will ever achieve what they have, but I am saying that it is too early to pronounce final judgement on him, and WAY too early to say that "we know he sucks."

One thing that I can pronounce judgement upon is that I will take the opinions of Art Rooney, Kevin Colbert, and Mike Tomlin and their counterparts across the NFL over the Hot Takes of sports radio talk jocks every day of the week.

Sunday, March 15, 2020

Super Bowl XIII - A Football (and Cultural) Time Capsule


With time on my hands and with no actual sports to watch, I pulled out a DVD set that I have owned for a number of years, a six disc set that has the complete telecast of all six Super Bowls won by the Pittsburgh Steelers.  In all the years that I have owned this, I had only watched one of the games, but on Friday night, I decided to watch the telecast of Super Bowl XIII, the one where the Steelers defeated the Cowboys 35-31.  Early on it became apparent that I was not only revisiting a happy sports memory, but I was also seeing a time capsule of sorts, so I began making some notes, and I will share some of those thoughts with you.  Football, television, and the Super Bowl itself were very different forty-one years ago than those institutions are today.

The game was televised by NBC.  Curt Gowdy, "the man who has described more major sporting events than anyone else", did the play-by-play with color by John Brodie and Merlin Olsen.  The "host" announcer, the guy who did the pregame (what little was included on the DVD) was a very young Dick Enberg.  Player introductions were handled by the Orange Bowl p.a. announcer and consisted only of the offensive starters for each team.  Very little hype and hoopla associated with these introductions, although the famed Cowboys Cheerleaders did form an aisle for the players to run through.  My first thought when I saw Terry Bradshaw was "wow, it looks like he hasn't put his shoulder pads on yet", but, no, he had them, or something that resembled shoulder pads, on and that is what he wore throughout the game.  

Note the puny shoulder pads on the QB

There was none of the hype associated with Super Bowl pre-game stuff today, but there was a preview of things to come when as the captains gathered for the coin toss, a vintage 1920 automobile drove onto the field with NFL  patriarch George Halas in the back seat.  Old Papa Bear was going to flip the coin to start the game.  As this was going on, a crossed wire on the radio frequency for the game officials caused the Pittsburgh radio broadcast to be heard on the telecast.  Yes, for about ten seconds, a national TV audience heard the dulcet tones of Myron Cope!!! Later in the telecast, Gowdy apologized for the technical glitch.

Before I give some of my stream-of-consciousness thoughts on the telecast, let's talk about the game itself.

The Steelers scored on their first possession with a Bradshaw to John Stallworth TD pass.  Stallworth actually had one foot land out of bounds in the end zone, but it was ruled that he was pushed while in the air and that he would have landed in bounds had the Dallas defender not hit him while he was coming down with the ball.  An official's judgement call perfectly permissible back then.  Today, it would have been an incomplete pass.

Dallas scored the next two TD's, the second one coming when a Cowboy defender stripped the ball from Bradshaw's grasp and ran it in for a touchdown. It was now 14-7 Dallas.  On the third play after the kickoff, Bradshaw hit Stallworth on a crossing pattern that resulted in a 75 yard TD pass and run, an play that Steelers fans have seen a zillion times over the years, which included a punishing block by Lynn Swann that helped free up Stallworth.  It was now 14-14, and the announcers noted that this was the first time in Super Bowl history that four touchdowns had been scored in a half.

Stallworth goes 75 yard to even the score at 14-14

Shortly before the end of the half, Bradshaw connected with Rocky Bleier for a TD that put the Steelers up 21-14 at the half.  Gowdy, Olsen, and Brodie were going on and on about the "fireworks" produced by these two teams in the first half and what could possibly happen to top it in the second half.  This game, according to them, was already "the greatest Super Bowl ever."

An acrobatic Bleier puts the Steelers  
up 21-14 just before halftime

The third quarter produced only one score, a field goal by Dallas after the play when a wide open in the end zone Jackie Smith dropped a sure pass that would have produced a touchdown and tied the game.  Both Steelers and Cowboys fans well remember the play.


A dropped pass by Jackie Smith forces the 
Cowboys to settle for a FG

The fourth quarter proceeded at the same pace as the third until late in the period.  On a play in Dallas territory, Franco Harris began jawing with a Dallas defender who, in Harris' opinion, took a cheap shot at Bradshaw after the play.  On the very next play, Bradshaw handed it off to an obviously pissed off Harris, who ran 23 untouched yards over left guard for a touchdown that put the Steelers up 28-17.  The hole that was opened up for Harris by Gerry Mullins, Sam Davis, and Mike Webster was so huge that Olsen and Brodie were marveling over the execution of the play.

Franco Harris rumbles for 23 untouched 
yards and and a 28 -17 Steelers lead 

What followed was a play that I did not remember.  The kickoff following the Harris TD was fumbled by Dallas and recovered by the Steelers' Dennis "Dirt" Winston.  The fumble was forced, by the way, by a young Steelers special teamer who had a bright future ahead of him - Tony Dungy. Anyway, on the very next play, Bradshaw went for the jugular and hit Swann in the end zone that put the Steelers up 35-17 and, effectively, ended the game.  The Steelers had scored two touchdowns in :11 of elapsed game time.

Swann's amazing leap makes it 35-17 Steelers

That's four Hall of Famers in this picture, folks!

With a little over four minutes remaining, Dallas got the ball back, and more specifically, Roger Staubach got the ball back and led the Cowboys to a touchdown to make it 35-24 with 2:24 on the clock.  Dallas then recovered an onside klick (that went through the hands of Dungy), and Staubach again drove them down field, including one conversion an a 4th and 18 play, and scored another touchdown to make it 35-31 with :22 remaining in the game.  A second attempt at an onside kick failed when the sure handed Bleier recovered the kick.  Staubach, far and away the best Dallas player on the team that night, made it interesting, but in retrospect, that four point win made the game appear closer than it actually was.  Still, I'm glad that Bleier recovered that second onside kick!

Thus, the Steelers of Chuck Noll became the "first team in history to win three Super Bowls".  Noll and the team would add one more the following year.

Okay, that was the game, and it was a great game, but what about some of those other factors that made viewing this game like opening a time capsule?  Let me list some of them here, as well as one other notable moments from the telecast.
  • The telecast was almost primitive compared to what you see on a televised  game today.  No graphics.  The picture did not show the score of the game, the time remaining, the down and distance, and there sure as hell was no yellow line to show the first down line to gain!  The TV didn't show the clock at all until there was four minutes remaining in the first half.  Amazing how used we have become to such amenities in a telecast.
  • Oh, and very limited use of Instant Replay, and, of course, no coaches' challenges or booth replay reviews.
  • Right after the coin toss NBC, via a pretaped segment, allowed all game officials to introduce themselves.  They don't do that anymore, and you're lucky if the announcers even tell you the name of the Referee.  That's too bad.  Among the Zebras in SB XIII were Pittsburghers Jerry Bergman, Head Linesman, and Chuck "Ace" Heberling, one of the Alternates.  Jerry Bergman, passed away a few years ago, and two of his sons, Jeff and Jerry, are currently officials in the NFL and both have worked in Super Bowls. The younger Jerry is also a former co-worker and a personal friend of mine.
  • The helmets the players wore in 1979 were small and toy-like compared to the helmets worn in 2020.  It wasn't exactly the leather helmets worn by the pioneers of the game, but let's just say that helmet technology has sure come a long way.
  • Hitting.  Both Staubach and Bradshaw were subject to cringe worthy hits by defensive players, plays that would draw penalties, if not ejections, today.  After one particularly crushing hit absorbed by Bradshaw, Merlin Olsen made it a point to note that it was not a "cheap shot."
  • At one point early in the telecast, Gowdy commented on all of the Steelers fans in the Orange Bowl who were waiving their "dirty towels."  Olsen quickly corrected him.  "They're Terrible Towels, Curt. Terrible Towels."  It was also commented upon that Steelers fans far outnumbered Cowboys fans in the Orange Bowl that day.
  • After four catches, two TD's, and 100+ yards, Stallworth was hurt late in the first half and did not play in the second half.  I did not remember that.
  • Lynn Swann more than made up for the absence of Stallworth. Man, oh, man, was Lynn Swann good.  Of course, I knew that.  I saw him play, and he is in the Hall of Fame, but I have to admit that I fear that I have forgotten just HOW GOOD he was.  Antonio Brown, you were a great receiver for the Steelers, but you were no Lynn Swann.
  • Jack Ham.  Another great player.  GREAT.  Jack Lambert is probably remembered more fondly by Steelers fans, and he was great, to be sure, but I think that after Joe Greene, Ham was the next best defender of that Steelers Era.
  • Mel Blount was 6'3", 205 pounds.  He looked as big as the defensive linemen out there.  Another guy that was just amazing to watch.
  • On the Dallas side, Roger Staubach was, as I said, the best player on that team, or at least he was that night.  Staubach had and still has the reputation of being the All-American Boy, Frank Merriwell-type, Aw Shucks kind of player, but he was anything but that after Smith dropped that pass in the end zone.  He was one totally PO'd guy coming off the field after that play.
  • Other Dallas players who stood out to me watching that game were safety Cliff Harris, defensive linemen Randy White, who played the game with a cast on one hand, and Too Tall Jones, and, of course, Tony Dorsett.
  • Also seen on the Dallas side line were HC Tom Landry looking natty in a camel's hair sport coat, necktie, and a felt fedora, and assistants Ernie Stautner and Mike Ditka, who looked ridiculous with his hair in a curly-haired perm.
  • At one point it was noted that during the regular season, Steelers place kicker Roy Gerela was 12 for 26 on field goal attempts during the season.  Guys would get cut for that in the NFL today, and, in fact, Gerela was gone from the Steelers after that season.
  • In this game, Franco Harris became the all time leading rusher in Super Bowl history.
  • The Steelers did not run a single play out of a shotgun formation.  The Cowboys ran the shotgun maybe a half dozen times.
  • Bradshaw called all of his own plays.  ALL OF HIS OWN PLAYS.  Quarterbacks actually used to do that.
  • Also in this game, Terry Bradshaw recorded the first 300 yard passing game of his nine year career (17/30, 317, 4 TD, 1 INT).  Generations of football fans know Bradshaw only as the buffoonish talking head on the Fox pregame shows, but fewer and fewer fans remember him as the very great HOF quarterback that he was.  That's a shame, but Terry is laughing al the way to the bank, so maybe he's okay with that.
  • When Dallas got the ball with four-plus minutes remaining and down 35-17, John Brodie made the statement that this wasn't over yet, that he remembered a game when Staubach beat his 49'ers by scoring fourteen points with his team never getting the ball back.  Gowdy says, "Oh, yeah that was that famous game in San Francisco a few years ago."  Brodie replied, "Famous for some people maybe..."  Good line.
  • Late in the game, the announcers began to comment that the dropped pass by Smith in the third quarter was looming large for Dallas and wasn't it too bad that a 16 year vet like Smith had to bear that burden.  Brodie made the point that it was totally unfair.  "No single play in the third quarter of a football game decides a game."  
  • In spite of my quoting Brodie here, the best announcer in the booth that day was Merlin Olsen.  He was really, really good.  He died in 2010 at the age of 70, and its probably just as well that he never had to listen to Booger McFarland broadcast a football game.
  • The DVD of the game did not include any commercials.  I wonder if the Super Bowl commercials then were as big a deal as they were to become?
  • Nor did the DVD include the halftime show.  A search on the Google Machine tells me that the halftime show was "Bob Jani presents Carnival: A Salute to the Caribbean."  Looks like the NFL and the Super Bowl were already moving away from marching bands and dogs chasing frisbees back in 1979. And, no, I have no idea as to who Bob Jani was, nor the inclination to look him up.
  • The announcement that Terry Bradshaw was the unanimous selection for MVP of the game came with over four minutes remaining in the game.  That could have been embarrassing had the Steelers failed to recover that second onside kick and given Staubach one more crack at the Steelers prevent defense.
  • Throughout the second half, Gowdy kept hyping a new show on NBC, "Brothers and Sisters", which will "debut on most of these NBC stations immediately following the telecast of this game."  Anyone have any memory of that show?  I don't.
Like I said, it was a fun and interesting viewing experience, but there was one sad part as well: the realization of how many people, most of them young and vibrant at the time, are no longer with us.  Chuck Noll, Mike Webster, Dwight White, LC Greenwood, Sam Davis, Steve Furness, George Perles, both Art and Dan Rooney, Tom Landry, Ernie Stautner, and other guys from the Cowboys of whom I am not aware.  Sobering.

Anyway, sorry that this post has rambled on longer than usual, but the subject matter was just too vast to allow for conciseness.

Once again, that final score, the Super Bowl Champion Pittsburgh Steelers 35, the Dallas Cowboys 31.



The Quarterbacks




Monday, December 26, 2016

Steelers 31 - Ravens 27


I watched the Steelers' big Christmas Day match-up with Ravens amidst the bustle of a house filled with family following a superb Christmas dinner, so it was festive atmosphere in the household, and the two teams sure gave us a whale of a contest as a Christmas gift.

By now, you all know what happened.  A 31 point fourth quarter that was an inverse of the Dallas game of a few weeks.  This time, it was the Ravens who lost a late lead, only to gain it back in the closing minutes, only to cough it up again in the closing seconds of the game on the spectacular play at the goal line by Antonio Brown pictured above.  This was the culmination of a 75 yard drive led by Ben Roethlisberger that took fifty-nine seconds to complete.  

In a game wherein Big Ben threw two almost soul-crushing interceptions, he came back in the fourth quarter to lead the Steelers on not one, not two, but THREE fourth quarter touchdown drives to pull out this come-from-behind win that clinched the AFC North for the Steelers and the third seed in the AFC playoffs.  Let's pull out all the cliches for this one...when the chips are down, when you're back is to the wall, when the cold wind blows,  when hope is gone, and your team is down, and facing long, if now impossible odds, to pull out a victory, is there any quarterback you would rather have leading your team than Ben Roethlisberger?  As great as Terry Bradshaw was, and he WAS great, if he started a game poorly, or threw a couple of critical interceptions (as Ben did yesterday), chances were that that was the Bradshaw you would have seen for the rest of the game.  Not so with Roethlisberger. As long as he is manning the controls and the game is within reach, the Steelers will have a chance to win the game.  He has done it time and again over the course of his career.




********

So, here is what I had to say back on September 9 when the Steelers were about to begin the season:

In 2016, the Pittsburgh Steelers are going to win twelve games, win the AFC North Division and gain first round playoff bye, win the AFC Championship, and win the Super Bowl.  I'm not going to make a prediction as to who they will play in the Super Bowl, because, who cares?  The Steelers are going to take home that seventh Lombardi Trophy.  

If you count them up, there are five predictions in that paragraph:
  1. The Steelers will win twelve games.  Okay, so the best they can do is eleven wins.  I'll take it.
  2. The Steelers will win the AFC North Division.  I believe I had that.
  3. The Steelers will gain a first round playoff bye.  Didn't happen, but they will be at Heinz Field in the first round against the #6 seed. Again, I'll take it.
  4. The Steelers will win the AFC Championship.
  5. The Steelers will win the Super Bowl.
I am standing by Numbers 4 and 5.

********

Speaking of Terry Bradshaw, he was in the news again last week for his comments about Mike Tomlin who, according the Bradshaw, is just "not a very good head coach".  Is he kidding us?  Bradshaw has spent most of his post playing career making outrageous comments about Steelers coaches, and this is just the latest.  He is quite good in his role as a Fox studio analyst/talking head, but he has been at it for so long that he as become, as someone has noted, a caricature of himself, and this comment seems to support that theory.

My buddy Jim Haller has urged be to bestow one of these upon Old Number 12:




However, for all that Bradshaw has done for the Steelers as a player - there are those four Lombardi Trophies, after all - I just can't bring myself to bestow an official Grandstander  H.A. Citation upon him.  He deserves better than that, but he also deserves NOT to be taken seriously when he makes such ridiculous comments as the ones he made about Tomlin last week.

Sunday, July 26, 2015

Pittsburgh Steelers "Franchise Four"

The recent promotion by Major League Baseball to name the "Franchise Four" for each team (and a word on that at the end of this post) prompted Joe Aro, a Facebook Friend of mine from the Washington DC area to name his "Franchise Four" for the Washington Redskins.  Fair enough, and it prompted me to try to list a Franchise Four for the Pittsburgh Steelers.

After putting much thought and analysis into it - maybe fifteen or twenty minutes of thinking about it - I came up with these four:


Joe Greene

I mean, really, do I have to justify this choice?  Simply put, the Greatest Steeler Ever.



Ernie Stautner

A Hall of Famer, he is here for the simple reason that people need to be aware that the Steelers existed and had great players before the 1972 season.


Jack Ham

Tough and smart, he may have been the best and most consistent defensive player of a team that was filled with Hall of Fame (and HOF caliber) defensive players.

The fourth guy has to be a quarterback, and I went back and forth between these two guys. Both were (and are) great.  One has greater stats than the other, but an argument can be made that the stats for each of them are a function of the era in which that played, but each of them, I contend, would have excelled and been great, no matter the era. In the end, only one stat separates the two - four Super Bowl rings vs. two Super Bowl rings, so here is the fourth guy.


Terry Bradshaw

It is a very narrow margin, and on any given day I could still be talked into including this guy:


Ben Roethlisberger

I ran this whole idea around at breakfast yesterday with Dan Bonk, Len Martin, Jim Haller, and Dave Finoli, and, of course, there was no unanimity.  The two names most mentioned who should be on the list were Franco Harris and Mel Blount, and I would have no argument if either of those guys, especially Harris, were in the Steelers' Franchise Four, so let's a salute them here:


Franco Harris


Mel Blount

Oh, and I mentioned that I would have a word on MLB's Franchise Four selections.  The name of Walter Johnson does not surface anywhere.  Not on the Minnesota Twins list, not on the Texas Rangers list, nor, even, and this is really stretching it, the Washington Nationals list.  That perhaps the greatest pitcher of all time cannot find his way on any of these lists calls the whole process into question, but I guess no one said that this would be anything more than a popularity contest decided by people raised in the era that says "if it wasn't on ESPN, it didn't happen."

Monday, December 1, 2014

Saints 35 - Steelers 32...Some Thoughts

Some thoughts on yet another Steelers loss to a team with a losing record....

  • If you watched the game, you know how misleading that three point deficit in the final score really is.
  • I was sure glad to see Ike Taylor return to the line-up.  Made you realize how little you missed him in his absence.
  • Yep, the QB had a bad game yesterday.  When that happens, others, particularly your defense, should step up to compensate. They didn't.
  • There sure is a huge drop off at the WR position after Antonio Brown.  Martavis Bryant has shown flashes that he can become an elite receiver, but yesterday showed that he ain't there yet.
  • This season is going to come to a close and the Steelers are going to find themselves STILL in the position of having to replace veterans Keisel, Polamalu, Harrison, and Taylor.  This will be at least the third season in a row that those needs have to be addressed.  Will it finally happen?
  • The best thing the Steelers have going for them is the fact that they play the division leading Bengals twice.  Simply put, they HAVE to win both those games.  If they don't, it probably won't matter what they do in the games against the Falcons and Chiefs.

This season the Steelers are celebrating the 40th Anniversary of their first Super Bowl Championship team, and good for them.  Yesterday, they had a reunion of surviving members of that team. There were two notable absences, QB Terry Bradshaw and LB Jack Lambert, both Hall of Famers.  Despite the fact that he has a job with Fox Sports that requires him to work on Sundays, Bradshaw will no doubt be criticized severely by Steelers faithful for not being there.  Lambert will get a compete and total pass from those same people.

Make of that what you will.

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

Bradshaw vs. Roethlisberger



As Steelers fans are no doubt aware, in last week's game against the Titans, Ben Roethlisberger surpassed Terry Bradshaw's Steeler team record for career passing yards.  The number is over 27,000 yards.

This made for lots of fun debate on the talk shows and in the papers as to who is/was the better quarterback, Terry or Ben.  As you might expect, much of this broke down on generational lines with, ahem, older Steelers fans favoring Bradshaw over Roethlisberger.  A strong case can be made for either one of them.  Comparing statistics might not be fair either because, and this was pointed out by many, the game played in the NFL in the 2010's is quite different than the one played in the 1970's.

Personally, I think that either player could switch eras and excel at the position.   Someone stated that if Roethlisberger played in the 1970's with his size and strength and with the Steelers defense to complement him, he would never lose a game.  Could very well be, but people forget that Bradshaw was a big guy at the time he played, and while he looks small compared to Ben, I have no doubt that if a 29 year old Terry Bradshaw was playing in the NFL today, he would be right up there with the Mannings, Rodgers, Bradys, and, yes, Roethlisbergers of today.  Personally, I'd have loved to see what Bradshaw could have done throwing it 40 time a game.

People will always point to Super Bowl Rings and give Terry with four an edge over Ben, who has two.  True enough, but we often forget that Super Bowls are won by teams, not individuals, so I don;t think this is a totally fair point of judgement.  

If forced to choose only one of them, my vote goes to Roethlisberger by a narrow margin, and here's why.  If you can remember, if Bradshaw started a game poorly, threw an interception or two, he almost never was able to turn it around in mid-game and change a poor start into a good game.  Roethlisberger has shown the ability over time to be able to shrug off a bad play or a poor start and turn what looked like a bad game into a good one, often resulting in a Steelers win.  That is completely subjective and intangible, but that's how I'm going.